{"schema_version":6,"evaluation":{"evaluation_date":"2026-08-11","suppression_sources":[{"path":".bifrost/suppressions.json","state":"not_found"},{"path":".bifrost/suppressions.private.json","state":"not_found"},{"path":".bifrost/suppressions.local.json","state":"not_found"}],"scope_path":".bifrost/policy-scope.json","scope_document_state":"not_found"},"execution":{"total_elapsed_ms":0,"stage_timings":[],"termination":null,"terminal_stage":null,"active_policy_id":null,"completed_policy_ids":[],"pending_policy_ids":[]},"rules":[{"policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","policy_hash":"0c8b43a7b1813309a051cfd9f3823e8a7de4e46d2655fad8e63fa70a2a3eb62d","analysis_type":"taint","policy_schema":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"},"selector_schemas":[{"path":"/analysis/sinks/entries/sink/selector","resolution":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"}},{"path":"/analysis/sources/entries/input/selector","resolution":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"}}],"endpoint_dependencies":[{"identity":{"type":"local","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","entry_id":"input"},"definition_schema":{"type":"policy_document","resolution":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"}},"selector_path":"/analysis/sources/entries/input/selector","selector_schema":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"},"model":{"role":"source","display_name":"benchmark input","categories":["input.user-controlled"],"binding":{"type":"return_value"},"taint":{"type":"source","labels":["attacker-controlled"],"threat_model":null,"evidence":null},"supersedes":[]},"semantic_hash":"f7780d92dcd6f2de2f0aff33c89a9b794cf6a2edb51698c5cfa86a1f138c4886","analysis_projection_hash":"8b33a5fb14946cad59607f223a3cbe958cf9af252bd9ae91ca634b05fa0748a5","origins":[{"type":"policy_local","path":"/analysis/sources/entries/input"}]},{"identity":{"type":"local","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","entry_id":"sink"},"definition_schema":{"type":"policy_document","resolution":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"}},"selector_path":"/analysis/sinks/entries/sink/selector","selector_schema":{"version":1,"origin":"explicit"},"model":{"role":"sink","display_name":"benchmark sink","categories":["data.sensitive"],"binding":{"type":"argument_index","index":0},"taint":{"type":"sink","accepts":["attacker-controlled"],"tags":[],"impacts":[]},"supersedes":[]},"semantic_hash":"ea1ac1830d5bdcf2bcdfaefdf5c4357a6aeb6e9ee65dc175f08aff1babb931c9","analysis_projection_hash":"78d18b1abd85019d3beb87d8a6f1203b466c8c2fe2d005a0eef40b5bd9b71d16","origins":[{"type":"policy_local","path":"/analysis/sinks/entries/sink"}]}],"match_directory_manifests":[],"endpoint_set_dependencies":[],"precedence_manifest":{"edges":[]},"name":"DataFlowBench PHP propagation kernel","message":{"type":"static","text":"Controlled input reaches the benchmark sink"},"severity":{"type":"fixed","level":"warning"},"description":null,"help_uri":null,"tags":[]}],"runs":[{"policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","policy_hash":"0c8b43a7b1813309a051cfd9f3823e8a7de4e46d2655fad8e63fa70a2a3eb62d","analysis_type":"taint","completion":{"type":"inconclusive","reasons":["partial_discovery"],"scope":{"type":"files","files":["mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php"],"truncated":false}},"findings":[{"id":"495e5e06a90be6c89ec48db315e988ab34f4719493f3d14b37de070558b29c46","identity_stability":"strong","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","policy_hash":"0c8b43a7b1813309a051cfd9f3823e8a7de4e46d2655fad8e63fa70a2a3eb62d","analysis_type":"taint","severity":"warning","message":"Controlled input reaches the benchmark sink","classification":{"type":"unclassified"},"certainty":{"type":"possible","reasons":[{"type":"analyzer_ambiguity","code":"taint-unproven-path"}]},"completeness":{"type":"partial","reasons":["proof_partial"]},"primary":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"related":[{"relationship":"source","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"evidence_refs":[]}],"related_truncated":false,"omitted_related_locations_lower_bound":0,"evidence":{"type":"taint","evidence":{"analysis_finding_id":"bifrost:48b9cc34e96acdc621b5f54570a929c10d3e185c6ec42085653e5ac4b31060c8","anchor":{"type":"strong","sink_identity":{"namespace":"php","path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","derivation":"canonical_ast_identity","semantic_key":"[[\"file\",\"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php\"],[\"function\",\"run\"],[\"program_point\",null]]"},"sink_site_ordinal":0,"source_endpoint_analysis_projection_hash":"8b33a5fb14946cad59607f223a3cbe958cf9af252bd9ae91ca634b05fa0748a5","sink_endpoint_analysis_projection_hash":"78d18b1abd85019d3beb87d8a6f1203b466c8c2fe2d005a0eef40b5bd9b71d16","source_scenario_set_hash":"93883241c4c44d4989f0994c20a7f5e87268876e8b67bfbdfe5904979ae8a33e"},"sink":"bifrost:4bb9b22e2a09cf0b2a29aaf6bb8eb3122218dee3b99ca3ca8426cd0506bf49b5","source_endpoint":{"type":"local","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","entry_id":"input"},"sink_endpoint":{"type":"local","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","entry_id":"sink"},"source_display_name":"benchmark input","source_threat_model":null,"sink_display_name":"benchmark sink","source_categories":["input.user-controlled"],"sink_categories":["data.sensitive"],"selected_combination":null,"sink_tags":[],"sink_impacts":[],"reached_source_labels":["attacker-controlled"],"origins":[{"source_endpoint":{"type":"local","policy_id":"dataflowbench.taint.core-php-kernel","entry_id":"input"},"source_label":"attacker-controlled","source_threat_model":null,"source_evidence":null,"primary":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"scenario_id":"bifrost:fda396cc66ae6e66572d486625a46374b8dcce079d41e8cb53d5afbf27a35e3a:source-event:0","evidence_refs":["bifrost:ac8915314dc526c4f6926a00320bcdb382676cba5b8eadb23b95361fd07e5ddb"],"certainty":{"type":"possible","reasons":[{"type":"analyzer_ambiguity","code":"taint-uncertain-origin-path"}]}}],"origins_truncated":false,"source_scenarios":["bifrost:fda396cc66ae6e66572d486625a46374b8dcce079d41e8cb53d5afbf27a35e3a:source-event:0"],"source_scenarios_truncated":false,"omitted_source_scenarios_lower_bound":0,"source_scenario_set_hash":"93883241c4c44d4989f0994c20a7f5e87268876e8b67bfbdfe5904979ae8a33e","witness_refs":["bifrost:45fdc44f0d40e8e3f51780d7e9149bff77ecdc4342148b06a1fdb19d173ea4cf","bifrost:772470e8d56c54299f3c95095389b6a6a98cd519d5791c923dec89fd3db10d95","bifrost:d3feb3c0d048d1d2e23867a1f5347d99f1aa42132205fece576ca472eca605a0"],"witness_refs_truncated":false,"projection_facts_hash":"1231d4399bbfbbe41588692d737b788a6cf18fd4bdc069b58c2048d96beed6de"}},"evidence_refs_truncated":false,"omitted_evidence_refs_lower_bound":0,"cvss":null,"organizational_risk":null,"proof":{"state":"unproven","reasons":[{"type":"dataflow_witness"}],"evidence_refs":[]},"witnesses":[{"id":"bifrost:45fdc44f0d40e8e3f51780d7e9149bff77ecdc4342148b06a1fdb19d173ea4cf","steps":[{"kind":"source","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint source","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":862,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":29,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":901},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":38}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":876},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":13}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":882},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":19}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":893},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":30}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":229,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":9,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":235,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":5,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":245},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":15}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":250,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":20,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":253,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":23,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":270,"end":276},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":16,"end_line":11,"end_column":22}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"return","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint summary boundary","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]}],"truncated":false,"omitted_steps_lower_bound":0,"retained_bytes":6792},{"id":"bifrost:772470e8d56c54299f3c95095389b6a6a98cd519d5791c923dec89fd3db10d95","steps":[{"kind":"source","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint source","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":862,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":29,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":901},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":38}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":876},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":13}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":882},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":19}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":893},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":30}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":229,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":9,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":235,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":5,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":245},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":15}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":250,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":20,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":253,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":23,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":270,"end":276},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":16,"end_line":11,"end_column":22}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"return","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint summary boundary","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]}],"truncated":false,"omitted_steps_lower_bound":0,"retained_bytes":6792},{"id":"bifrost:d3feb3c0d048d1d2e23867a1f5347d99f1aa42132205fece576ca472eca605a0","steps":[{"kind":"source","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint source","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":841,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":28,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":862,"end":903},"region":{"start_line":29,"start_column":1,"end_line":31,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":901},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":38}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":876},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":13}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":882},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":19}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":893},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":30}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":897,"end":898},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":34,"end_line":30,"end_column":35}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":229,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":9,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":235,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":5,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":245},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":15}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":250,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":20,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":239,"end":251},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":9,"end_line":10,"end_column":21}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":253,"end":283},"region":{"start_line":10,"start_column":23,"end_line":12,"end_column":6}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":270,"end":276},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":16,"end_line":11,"end_column":22}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":263,"end":277},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":9,"end_line":11,"end_column":23}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"return","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint summary boundary","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"taint propagation","evidence_refs":[]}],"truncated":false,"omitted_steps_lower_bound":0,"retained_bytes":6792}],"witnesses_truncated":false,"omitted_witnesses_lower_bound":0,"display_path":{"schema_version":1,"representative_witness_id":"bifrost:45fdc44f0d40e8e3f51780d7e9149bff77ecdc4342148b06a1fdb19d173ea4cf","witness_ids":["bifrost:45fdc44f0d40e8e3f51780d7e9149bff77ecdc4342148b06a1fdb19d173ea4cf","bifrost:772470e8d56c54299f3c95095389b6a6a98cd519d5791c923dec89fd3db10d95","bifrost:d3feb3c0d048d1d2e23867a1f5347d99f1aa42132205fece576ca472eca605a0"],"steps":[{"kind":"source","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":883,"end":895},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":20,"end_line":30,"end_column":32}},"label":"dfb_source()"},{"kind":"call","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"walkA(dfb_source(), 3)"},{"kind":"propagation","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":270,"end":276},"region":{"start_line":11,"start_column":16,"end_line":11,"end_column":22}},"label":"$value"},{"kind":"return","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":185,"end":486},"region":{"start_line":8,"start_column":1,"end_line":16,"end_column":2}},"label":"function walkA(int $value, int $depth): int { if ($depth === 0) { return $value; } $next = $value + 1; $recursive = walkB($next, $depth - 1); // DFB-WITNESS:..."},{"kind":"return","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"label":"return from walkA(dfb_source(), 3)"},{"kind":"sink","location":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":868,"end":900},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":5,"end_line":30,"end_column":37}},"label":"dfb_sink(walkA(dfb_source(), 3))"}],"canonical_incomplete":true,"omitted_meaningful_steps":0,"alternatives_truncated":false,"omitted_alternative_paths_lower_bound":0,"omitted_witnesses_lower_bound":0},"suppression":null,"scope":null}],"diagnostics":[{"code":{"type":"evaluation_failure"},"severity":"warning","impact":"run_incomplete","family":"taint discovery is incomplete: call resolution is unknown","message":"taint discovery is incomplete: call resolution for mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php:mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php.run is unknown; this exact call has neither a completely resolved executable target nor an applicable complete external model; call `walkA` at mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php bytes 877..899 has snapshot input status unknown; the resolver edge is complete; resolver boundary status: dispatch_status=complete candidate_coverage=Exhaustive uncovered_boundary=false truncated=false arms=[] entered_targets=[DeclarationLocator([DeclarationSegment { kind: File, name: Some(\"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php\"), anchor: SourceAnchor { span: SourceSpan { start: SourcePosition { byte_offset: 0, line: 0, byte_column: 0 }, end: SourcePosition { byte_offset: 904, line: 31, byte_column: 0 } }, occurrence: 0 }, sibling_ordinal: 0 }, DeclarationSegment { kind: Function, name: Some(\"walkA\"), anchor: SourceAnchor { span: SourceSpan { start: SourcePosition { byte_offset: 185, line: 7, byte_column: 0 }, end: SourcePosition { byte_offset: 486, line: 15, byte_column: 1 } }, occurrence: 0 }, sibling_ordinal: 0 }])] binding_coverage=Some([Answered { status: Unknown }]); call semantic gap: unknown: call target requires whole-program dispatch refinement","family_count":1,"primary":{"path":"mutual_recursive_transform_positive.php","byte_span":{"start":877,"end":899},"region":{"start_line":30,"start_column":14,"end_line":30,"end_column":36}},"related":[]}],"diagnostics_truncated":false,"obligations":[],"obligations_truncated":false,"omitted_obligations_lower_bound":0,"work":{"scanned_files":2,"scanned_source_bytes":1808,"fact_nodes":220,"pipeline_rows":2,"examined_references":0,"retained_findings":1,"omitted_findings_lower_bound":0,"retained_report_bytes":33527,"metrics":[{"name":"taint.attribution_attempts","unit":"count","value":3},{"name":"taint.attribution_candidate_exhaustions","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.attribution_expansions","unit":"count","value":99},{"name":"taint.attribution_run_exhaustions","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.attribution_steps","unit":"count","value":96},{"name":"taint.compiled_sink_endpoints","unit":"count","value":1},{"name":"taint.compiled_source_endpoints","unit":"count","value":1},{"name":"taint.propagation_shared_memberships","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.propagation_solves","unit":"count","value":1},{"name":"taint.selector_scans","unit":"count","value":2},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_allocations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_blocks","unit":"rows","value":35},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_call_sites","unit":"rows","value":20},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_captures","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_control_edges","unit":"rows","value":114},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_events","unit":"rows","value":291},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_evidence","unit":"rows","value":226},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_gaps","unit":"rows","value":201},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_memory_locations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_nested_entries","unit":"rows","value":1264},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_owned_text_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":17410},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_procedures","unit":"rows","value":15},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_program_points","unit":"rows","value":351},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_source_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":2712},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_source_mappings","unit":"rows","value":164},{"name":"taint.semantic_cumulative_values","unit":"rows","value":237},{"name":"taint.semantic_handle_identity_reuses","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_materialized_files","unit":"count","value":2},{"name":"taint.semantic_peak_retained_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":17410},{"name":"taint.semantic_peak_row_dimension","unit":"rows","value":1161},{"name":"taint.semantic_peak_traversal_steps","unit":"count","value":21},{"name":"taint.semantic_program_points","unit":"rows","value":351},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_allocations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_blocks","unit":"rows","value":35},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_call_sites","unit":"rows","value":5},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_captures","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_control_edges","unit":"rows","value":114},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_events","unit":"rows","value":97},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_evidence","unit":"rows","value":164},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_gaps","unit":"rows","value":36},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_memory_locations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_nested_entries","unit":"rows","value":1015},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_owned_text_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":17410},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_procedures","unit":"rows","value":5},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_program_points","unit":"rows","value":117},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_retained_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":17410},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_source_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":904},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_source_mappings","unit":"rows","value":164},{"name":"taint.semantic_resident_peak_values","unit":"rows","value":62},{"name":"taint.semantic_result_contract_artifact_leases","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_allocations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_blocks","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_call_sites","unit":"rows","value":10},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_captures","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_control_edges","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_events","unit":"rows","value":178},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_evidence","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_gaps","unit":"rows","value":165},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_memory_locations","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_nested_entries","unit":"rows","value":146},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_owned_text_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_procedures","unit":"rows","value":3},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_program_points","unit":"rows","value":212},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_source_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":904},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_source_mappings","unit":"rows","value":0},{"name":"taint.semantic_root_work_peak_values","unit":"rows","value":122},{"name":"taint.semantic_snapshot_materializations","unit":"count","value":5},{"name":"taint.semantic_source_bytes","unit":"bytes","value":1808},{"name":"taint.semantic_traversal_steps","unit":"count","value":36},{"name":"taint.store_key_budget_hits","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.store_key_direct_literals","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.store_key_operands","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.store_key_recovered","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.store_key_unproven","unit":"count","value":0},{"name":"taint.store_key_work","unit":"count","value":0}]},"engine":{"icfg":{"reason":"language:php"}}}],"suppressions":[],"scope":[],"packs":{"document_path":".bifrost/packs.json","dependency_mode":"default","ecosystems":["composer"],"complete":true,"decisions":[{"pack":"bifrost.php-builtin","status":"rejected","reason":"php: the workspace declares no PHP version in .php-version or composer.json"}],"decisions_truncated":false},"diagnostics":[],"diagnostics_truncated":false,"omitted_diagnostics_lower_bound":0,"worst_omitted_diagnostic_severity":null}